Bhool Chuk Maaf: A Time-Loop Rom-Com That Tries Hard but Falls Short

Bhool Chuk Maaf (translated as “Forgive My Mistakes”) is a 2025 Indian Hindi-language science fiction romantic comedy that promised to blend small-town charm, time-loop intrigue, and Rajkummar Rao’s signature everyman charisma. Directed by Karan Sharma and produced by Dinesh Vijan’s Maddock Films in collaboration with Amazon MGM Studios, the film stars Rajkummar Rao and Wamiqa Gabbi, supported by a talented ensemble including Sanjay Mishra, Raghubir Yadav, Seema Pahwa, and Zakir Hussain. Set against the vibrant backdrop of Varanasi, the movie aims to deliver a heartwarming tale of love, fate, and redemption. But does it live up to the hype? In this in-depth review, we’ll explore the film’s plot, performances, themes, technical aspects, release journey, and audience reception to determine whether Bhool Chuk Maaf is a cinematic gem or a missed opportunity.

Release Date and the Theatrical-OTT Saga

Bhool Chuk Maaf faced a tumultuous journey to its release. Initially slated for a theatrical premiere on May 9, 2025, the film was abruptly shifted to a direct-to-OTT release on Amazon Prime Video on May 16, 2025, due to escalating India-Pakistan tensions following the Pahalgam attack. The producers, citing “heightened security drills across the nation,” prioritized national sentiment over a big-screen outing. This decision sparked significant backlash, particularly from PVR Inox, India’s leading multiplex chain, which filed a Rs 60 crore lawsuit against Maddock Films for breach of contract after over 5,000 tickets had been sold, generating Rs 3 crores in ticket sales. The Bombay High Court intervened, granting an ad-interim injunction that restrained the film from releasing on OTT platforms until completing an eight-week theatrical run, leading to a compromise for a theatrical release on May 23, 2025, followed by an OTT release on June 6, 2025. This back-and-forth not only fueled industry debates about theatrical versus OTT release windows but also set a precedent for future distribution strategies.

The film’s release drama overshadowed its initial buzz, but it finally hit theaters, giving audiences a chance to experience Ranjan and Titli’s quirky love story on the big screen. The question remains: was the theatrical experience worth the wait?

Plot: A Time-Loop Tale with Small-Town Charm

Bhool Chuk Maaf follows Ranjan Tiwari (Rajkummar Rao), a lovable but unemployed young man from Varanasi, who dreams of marrying his vivacious girlfriend, Titli Mishra (Wamiqa Gabbi). However, Titli’s father, Brijmohan (Zakir Hussain), imposes a condition: Ranjan must secure a government job within two months to prove his worth. Desperate, Ranjan turns to the street-smart Bhagwan Das (Sanjay Mishra) for a “jugaad” solution to land a sarkari naukri. Just when things seem to fall into place, Ranjan finds himself trapped in a bizarre time loop, waking up repeatedly on the morning of his Haldi ceremony, unable to progress to his wedding day. As he navigates this repetitive cycle, Ranjan grapples with an unfulfilled promise to Lord Shiva, weaving a narrative that blends humor, romance, and a touch of magic realism.

The premise is intriguing, combining the time-loop concept popularized by films like Groundhog Day with the vibrant, chaotic energy of Varanasi’s ghats and gullies. The story aims to explore themes of love, destiny, and personal growth, with a sprinkle of social commentary on issues like unemployment, dowry, and societal expectations. However, as many reviews note, the execution falters, leaving audiences wanting more coherence and emotional depth.

Performances: Rajkummar Rao Shines, but Chemistry Lags

Rajkummar Rao, known for his versatility and ability to embody the small-town everyman, delivers a commendable performance as Ranjan. His impeccable comic timing and earnest portrayal of a man caught in a frustrating loop keep the film afloat during its weaker moments. Critics have praised Rao’s ability to evoke empathy, even when the script fails to provide fresh material. However, some argue that his role feels repetitive, echoing characters from previous Maddock Films like Mimi and Luka Chuppi, raising concerns about typecasting.

Wamiqa Gabbi, as Titli, brings a lively energy to the screen, but her performance has divided audiences. While some appreciate her as a “livewire with a sense of purpose,” others find her character “borderline annoying” due to her over-the-top, childlike demeanor. The lack of palpable chemistry between Rao and Gabbi is a recurring criticism, with reviewers noting that their romance lacks the depth and spark needed to make the time-loop stakes feel compelling.

The supporting cast, including Sanjay Mishra, Raghubir Yadav, Seema Pahwa, and Zakir Hussain, delivers solid performances, but their limited screen time prevents them from elevating the film. Mishra’s Bhagwan Das adds a touch of humor, while Pahwa’s portrayal of Ranjan’s enterprising mother, who runs a pickle business, hints at untapped potential for deeper storytelling.

Themes and Social Commentary: A Mixed Bag

Bhool Chuk Maaf attempts to weave social commentary into its comedic narrative, touching on issues like unemployment, dowry, and the hypocrisy of societal norms. The film’s setting in Varanasi, a city steeped in spiritual and cultural significance, adds a layer of magic realism, with the time loop tied to an unfulfilled promise to Lord Shiva. The Hindu describes it as a “sharp social commentary disguised as a frothy comedy,” highlighting the everyday hypocrisy where actions don’t match preached values.

However, the film’s handling of these themes is inconsistent. Some reviews criticize its outdated humor, particularly a recurring pregnancy joke that trivializes childbirth, calling it “the easiest job in the world.” Others note that the social commentary feels tacked on, with a cliched monologue at the end that echoes similar resolutions in Rao’s previous films. The narrative’s attempt to address dowry and gender roles, such as Titli’s agency or Ranjan’s mother’s entrepreneurial spirit, is undermined by a lack of depth and resolution, leaving these issues feeling like comedic asides rather than meaningful commentary.

Technical Aspects: Visuals and Music Fall Flat

The film’s cinematography, while capturing Varanasi’s iconic ghats and bustling streets, is described as “old wine in a new bottle.” Critics lament the repetitive visuals—shots of the Ganges, boats, and bylanes—that fail to offer anything novel compared to other Bollywood films set in the city. The production design, including a set resembling a small-town street for a promotional song, adds some vibrancy, but it’s not enough to compensate for the lackluster visuals.

The soundtrack, composed by Tanishk Bagchi with lyrics by Irshad Kamil, is another weak link. Songs are described as “bland” and “forgettable,” failing to enhance the narrative or evoke emotion. The background score by Ketan Sodha is criticized for being overly heavy, undermining the lightness needed for a rom-com. A recycled track, Chor Bazari from Love Aaj Kal, reportedly steals the show, highlighting the new compositions’ shortcomings.

Direction and Screenplay: A Promising Premise Undermined

Director Karan Sharma, making his mark with Bhool Chuk Maaf, shows ambition in blending genres but struggles to maintain coherence. The time-loop concept is a fresh addition to Bollywood, but the screenplay’s repetitive sequences and sluggish pacing, especially in the second half, dilute its impact. Critics note that the film takes over an hour to establish its central conflict, a flaw exacerbated by the trailer revealing much of the plot. The dialogue, while sharp in places, often feels forced, and the humor fails to land consistently.

Sharma’s attempt to balance comedy, romance, and social commentary results in a narrative that feels overstuffed yet hollow. The film’s 121-minute runtime feels stretched, with reviewers suggesting that tighter editing could have enhanced its appeal. The genre-bending ambitions are admirable, but the creative execution falls short, leaving audiences stuck in a loop of unfulfilled potential.

Audience and Critic Reception: A Divided Response

The film’s reception is mixed, with critics and audiences offering both praise and criticism. On X, some viewers call it a “heartwarming” and “timepass” watch, appreciating its feel-good moments and Rao’s performance. Taran Adarsh rated it 3.5 stars, describing it as a “smart rom-com” with a “solid finale” that redeems its flaws. Others, however, find it “disappointing,” “repetitive,” and “unbearable,” citing a flat screenplay, lack of humor, and weak chemistry. Ratings range from 1.5 to 3 stars, with some calling it Maddock Films’ weakest offering in recent years.

Critics echo these sentiments. The Indian Express compares it to a “poor man’s Brahmastra,” criticizing its lack of cohesion, while NDTV calls it a “tiring comedy” that “goes round and round in circles.” The Hindu offers a more positive take, praising its social commentary, but even they acknowledge the overwritten second half and bland music. Box office reports suggest a decent opening, with early trends indicating it as Rao’s fourth-highest opener, but its long-term success depends on word-of-mouth in Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities.

Box Office and Cultural Impact

Despite the mixed reviews, Bhool Chuk Maaf benefits from Rao and Gabbi’s appeal among youth and small-town audiences, with affordable ticket prices (Rs 150–200) potentially boosting its theatrical run. The film’s release drama has sparked broader discussions about the evolving dynamics between theatrical and OTT platforms, with the two-week OTT window setting a new benchmark. Industry experts see this as a turning point, emphasizing the need for clear communication and contractual clarity in film distribution.

Culturally, the film taps into Varanasi’s spiritual and chaotic charm, but its reliance on familiar tropes and lack of fresh humor limit its impact. While it aims to resonate with audiences through its small-town narrative and moral message about merit and karma, it struggles to stand out in a crowded rom-com landscape.

Should You Watch It?

Bhool Chuk Maaf is a film with a promising premise and a stellar cast but falters in execution. Rajkummar Rao’s performance and the unique time-loop concept are highlights, but the lack of chemistry, repetitive screenplay, and weak humor make it a one-time watch at best. If you’re a fan of Rao’s small-town comedies or enjoy light-hearted rom-coms with a touch of social commentary, it’s worth catching in theaters or on Amazon Prime Video after June 6, 2025. However, don’t expect a groundbreaking cinematic experience.

For those in Varanasi or fans of films that capture the city’s essence, the familiar setting might add some charm. But for a broader audience, the film’s flaws—outdated humor, sluggish pacing, and an underwhelming soundtrack—may outweigh its merits. If you’re looking for a mindless entertainer, it delivers sporadically, but don’t expect the magic of Maddock’s Stree or Luka Chuppi.

Final Verdict

Bhool Chuk Maaf is a well-intentioned rom-com that gets stuck in its own time loop of clichés and missed opportunities. Rajkummar Rao and the supporting cast shine, but the lackluster script, uneven direction, and repetitive narrative prevent it from soaring. It’s a film that tries to say something meaningful but ends up saying too little, too late. Watch it for Rao’s charm and a few heartfelt moments, but temper your expectations.

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)

Where to Watch: In theaters now; streaming on Amazon Prime Video from June 6, 2025.

For more Bollywood reviews, updates, and insights, keep visiting kishanbaraiya.com!